Ima asked:
Maybe you can enlighten me with some sources to check on this iniyan which has been nagging at me?
If all the maasim and even the thoughts to do these, all come from Hashem, bi’bechinat Ayin od milvado, where and what exactly is the nekudat habechira.
1. My thoughts are given to me from Above or from the outside world/metziyut,
2. my deeds are not mine, ie Hashem “does all”.
3. The Ratzon is also given from Above.
So where/what is this mysterious free choice?
Would like to study/check some sources, if you have any. Or any thoughts backed up by original sources…
Is “what we decide” inside ourselves, ie that fleeting split second decision, based on 1+2+3, called free will? And if so, what IS IT? How does it differ from 3. or Ratzon?
Free will is not even connected to “time” as it would appear, bec even Adam Harishon had free will and he was in Gan Eden/bina, above time as we know it עלמא דחירות
Thanks
I’m probably overthinking 😂
